DiCarlo's Pizza - Triadelphia has quickly established itself as a must-visit spot in the heart of West Virginia. Located at 355 Wharton Cir, this eatery offers a refreshing take on pizza that has been praised by locals and travelers alike. Customers rave about the unique Ohio Valley Style Pizza, where the provolone cheese and pepperoni are added after baking, resulting in a delightful fusion of flavors.
Tanya Novotny shares her experience of stopping in for two trays, declaring the pizza "excellent" and the cheese exceptional. Similarly, another customer highlights the joy of melted cheese that “restored their faith in pizza.” With a friendly and welcoming staff, like Terrell the baker, guests feel right at home. Molly Woods notes how their pepperoni rolls were a hit in the office, disappearing quickly and showcasing the delicious offerings.
With every visit, DiCarlo's Pizza - Triadelphia seems to create lasting impressions, whether it's for a quick bite or a family gathering. The combination of quality ingredients and a passionate team makes dining here an experience worth remembering. Make sure to stop by if you're passing through!
Amenities and More
Service options
Delivery
Takeaway
Dine-in
Highlights
Fast service
Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Offerings
Alcohol
Comfort food
Quick bite
Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Table service
Atmosphere
Casual
Crowd
Groups
Tourists
Planning
Accepts reservations
Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot
Parking
Pets
Dogs allowed outside
Photos
Reviews For DiCarlo's Pizza - Triadelphia
Tanya Novotny
Jun 28,2025
Stopped in this location today for 2 trays to take to family in the Columbus area . Excellent pizza! We all commented on on good the cheese was . Crust was as we like it as well. The staff was super friendly and helpful . This will be my new go to location when I travel from Pittsburgh to Ohio . Thanks !
Dreamer9412001
Jun 22,2025
You have to taste it to believe it . I asked to melt my cheese . It was amazing. I have stopped telling people about it . Restored my Faith in pizza !! ...
Molly Woods
Jun 11,2025
I work at the highlands and Dicarlos is always friendly, food is always terrific. I ordered 12 pepperoni roll for our office and they were great! I said we’re because everyone gobbled them up! Great staff!
David Brosius
Jun 10,2025
Upon arrival at my Hotel in Wheeling, I asked about a local restaurant that had something different. They recommended DiCarlo's Pizza - what a treat. The provolone cheese and pepperoni are put on the pizza AFTER it comes out of the oven. Ohio Valley Style Pizza! It was absolutely delicious... I will definitely come here again when I am in the area! Awesome Pizza!
Dave McBain
Jun 5,2025
Great pizza and easy ordering. Terrell, the baker, has a great personality and was very welcoming. My wife hadn’t had this pizza in over 15 years and it brought back great memories.
Fabo Holloway
May 15,2025
1st time here & eating the pizza. Good customer service. Ingredients are fresh and cook to perfection.
Austin S
May 6,2025
Why do people actually get on here and complain about the unmelted cheese? People are morons. The pizza we got tonight was delicious and as expected. The sauce was a tad spicy though. Not a problem for me but too spicy for my 2 year old.
Michelle Riedlinger
Apr 8,2025
Truly a different pizza! Tastes great just DON'T GET EXTRA CHEESE! Extra cheese isn't for this style of pizza!
Reviews For DiCarlo's Pizza - Triadelphia